A Metainferential Solution to the Adoption Problem (Federico Pailos and Eduardo Barrio)

The Logic and Metaphysics Workshop will meet on April 5th from 4:15-6:15 (NY time) via Zoom for a talk by Federico Pailos and Eduardo Barrio (Buenos Aires).

Title: A Metainferential Solution to the Adoption Problem

Abstract: In ‘The Question of Logic’ (Kripke 2020) and “The Adoption Problem and the Epistemology of Logic” (Padró 2020), Kripke and Padró argue against the possibility of adopting an alternative logic. Without having already endorsed a logic, it is not possible to derive the consequences of an alternative system. In particular, without Modus Ponens in the metatheory, one could not adopt any inferential rule at all. This seems to cause trouble for logics like LP, that does not validate this rule. Modus Ponens is a self-governing rule that cannot be adopted and could not be rejected. This is connected with the problem of the tortoise reasoner (Scambler 2019) and the problem of the tortoise Logic (Priest 2021). In this talk, we offer a new solution. With the metainferential logic TS/LP it is possible to model metalogical Modus Ponens-like reasoning while still rejecting Modus Ponens.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Need help with the Commons? Visit our
help page
Send us a message